Our Response To The University Of Louisville

Print More

The University of Louisville’s response to our recent story, “Top U of L Researcher Loses Federal Funding For Paralysis Study,” sent in an email to alumni, faculty and staff on Wednesday, makes spurious claims about our reporting.

The university had numerous opportunities to comment before the story was published and has not contacted KyCIR to challenge the story or any of the documented findings in it since its publication on Monday. Still, we want to address their claims in detail.

Federal funding was withdrawn from the study in question; our story details this and includes the source document from a federal department within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. The March 18 letter reads, in part: “[The agency] has decided that we will discontinue funding for this particular study, effective immediately.”

U of L claims none of the 151 “adverse events” referred to in our story were the result of the research. Our story does not make the counterclaim.

U of L also claims “medication compliance was taking place” and suggests it was a minor deviation. Our story reported that research records did not contain information about patients’ medical compliance, quoting the letter from HHS noting that as a major concern. Again, that source document is contained within the story.

March 18 letter from HHS to University of Louisville

March 18 letter from HHS to University of Louisville

KyCIR also provided the source documents for the story for review by three outside experts without ties to U of L, all of whom drew the same conclusions that are reflected in the story. Among those was Dr. Milton Corn, deputy director for research and education at the National Library of Medicine, who is quoted in the story.

We also provided the documents to several additional experts not quoted in the story who drew the same conclusions.

Beginning on June 22, we attempted to interview William Pierce, executive vice president for research and innovation at U of L, who co-authored the U of L letter. He declined to comment, which is reflected in the story. He declined comment on the matter again on Wednesday. We also attempted to get comment from the university’s Institutional Review Board, which conducted the audit; they declined. (Read the institutional review board’s audit report.)

And we gave the spokesperson for U of L’s Health Sciences Center an opportunity to discuss our findings three days before the story was published, but that person did not.

Perhaps most importantly, Dr. Susan Harkema — whose study is the subject of the story — is quoted throughout responding to our findings.

Harkema’s defense, as well that of Pierce and the university, is based upon the claim that alleged disgruntled employees brought negative and false information about her and the study to light. While one employee is named and quoted in our story, our reporting relied on federal and university documents which are, again, posted in full with the story.

The suggestion from U of L that our story contains inaccuracies of any kind is false and egregious, and is a transparent attempt to deflect recent attention arising from our reporting. We encourage anyone interested to compare their claims to our story and the original source documents and draw their own conclusions.

 

  • Jane Doe

    This explains why Dr Harkema and a university attorney held a meeting in June and made us sign a confidentiality agreement preventing us from talking to anyone about our work. It felt really intimidating, but I need the job and didn’t see any choice

    • Dan

      After putting 2 children through UofL, my wife and I retired and moved to Louisville in 2013. Ever since, I have read far too many stories of abuse of federal funds, former staff paid off after signing nondisclosure statements (hush money) and the failure of Dr. Ramsey to set an ethical tone at UofL. Students I speak with who attend UofL often hang their heads in shame when I ask them their opinion of Ramsey’s leadership and ethics. More energy is spent on squelching the truth than coming forward and simply accepting blame. While Dr. Ramsey has made efforts to grow the University and it’s reputation, he has failed miserably as the ultimate leader of the institution and made decisions that have only sullied UofL’s reputation, as described in the Chronical of Higher Education with a world-wide readership. Stop the questionable perks provided to this man who lacks integrity on both a local and national stage. KY consistently ranks near the bottom on educational achievement on several measures. Yet, Ramsey accepts salary “supplements” without batting an eyelash and Matt “Mussolini” Bevin cuts funding to public education without remorse as we sink further down in the rankings in educational achievement, access to healthcare and children of children living in poverty.

      • George Demic

        Dan,

        If you were elected governor and told, “Oh, by the way, you have been saddled by a $37 billion deficit due to criminal neglect by the previous administration and you will face obstacles at every turn because the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree,” would you start cleaning house? So go ahead, name call all you want, because all Republicans are racist, homophobic caricatures of Mussolini. . . or maybe we’re sick and tired of people like you who seek to destroy every effort you don’t agree with to right the ship. How ’bout you run for governor and let us take pot-shots at you?

  • Rob

    As a person with spinal cord injury who is always looking to keep myself healthy and regain as much function as possible, I want to THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU KyCIR for reporting this story. I also want to thank Dr. Williams for coming forward. This was a very courageous move and without people like you Dr. Williams people like me could be seriously hurt. You are the best doctor I have ever had, and I will always be grateful for your honest, integrity, and ethics. I only wish I could say the same thing about Dr. Harkema….